Erich Fromm, “Sanity” from The Sane Society (Henry Holt, 1955) and Escape from Freedom (Henry Holt, 1969). While it is true that man is molded by the necessities of the economic and social structure of society, he is not infinitely adaptable. Not only are there certain physiological needs that imperatively call for satisfaction, but there are also certain psychological qualities inherent in man that need to be satisfied and that result in certain reactions if they are frustrated. What are these qualities? The most important seems to be the tendency to grow, to develop and realize potentialities which man has developed in the course of history - as, for instance, the faculty of creative and critical thinking and of having differentiated emotional and sensuous experiences. ... This tendency can be suppressed and frustrated, but such suppres¬sion results in new reactions, particularly in the formation of destructive and symbiotic impulses. It also seems that this general tendency to grow ... Results in such specific tendencies as the desire for freedom and the hatred against oppression, since freedom is the fundamental condition for any growth. Again, the desire for freedom can be repressed, it can disappear from the awareness of the individual; but even then it does not cease to exist as a potentiality, and indicates its existence by the conscious or unconscious hatred by which such suppression is always accompanied. ... We believe that the realization of the self is accomplished not only by an act of thinking but also by the realization of man's total personality, by the active expres¬sion of his emotional and intellectual potentialities. These potentialities are present in everybody; they become real only to the extent to which they are expressed. In other words, positive freedom consists in the spontaneous activity of the total, integrated personality. Spontaneous activity is not compulsive activity, to which the individual is driven by his isolation and powerlessness; it is not the activity of the au¬tomaton, which is the uncritical adoption of patterns suggested from the outside. Spontaneous activity is free activity of the self and implies, psychologically, what the Latin root of the word, sponte, means literally: of one's free will. By activity we do not mean “doing something,” but the quality of creative activity that can operate in one's emotional, intellectual, and sensuous experiences and in one’s will as well. One premise for this spontaneity is the acceptance of the total personality and the elimination of the split between “reason” and “nature”; for only if man does not repress essential parts of his self, only if he has become transparent to himself, and only if the different spheres of life have reached a fundamental integration, is spontaneous activity possible. While spontaneity is a relatively rare phenomenon in our culture, we are not entirely devoid of it. In order to help in the understanding of this point, I should like to remind the reader of some instances where we all catch a glimpse of spontaneity. In the first place, we know of individuals who are - or have been - spontaneous, whose thinking, feeling, and acting were the expression of their selves and not of an automaton. These individuals are mostly known to us as artists. As a matter of fact, the artist can be defined as an individual who can express himself spontaneously. If this were the definition of an artist - Balzac defined him just in that way - then certain phi¬losophers and scientists have to be called artists too, while others are as different from them as an old-fashioned photogra¬pher from a creative painter. ... Small children offer another instance of spontaneity. They have an ability to feel and think that which is really theirs; this spontaneity shows in what they say and think, in the feelings that are expressed in their faces. If one asks what makes for the attraction small children have for most people I believe that, aside from sentimental and conventional reasons, the answer must be that it is this very quality of spontaneity. It appeals profoundly to everyone who is not so dead himself that he has lost the ability to perceive it. As a matter of fact, there is nothing more attractive and convincing than spontaneity whether it is to be found in a child, in an artist, or in those individuals who cannot thus be grouped according to age or profession. Most of us can observe at least moments of our own spontaneity which are at the same time moments of genuine happiness. Whether it be the fresh and spontaneous perception of a landscape, or the dawning of some truth as the result of our thinking, or a sensuous pleasure that is not stereotyped, or the welling up of love for another person - in these moments we all know what a spontaneous act is and may have some vision of what human life could be if these experiences were not such rare and uncultivated occurrences. Spontaneous activity is the one way in which man can overcome the terror of aloneness without sacrificing the integrity of his self; for in the spontaneous realization of the self man unites himself anew with the world - with man, nature, and himself. Love is the foremost component of such sponta¬neity; not love as the dissolution of the self in another person, not love as the possession of another person, but love as sponta¬neous affirmation of others, as the union of the individual with others on the basis of the preservation of the individual self. The dynamic quality of love lies in this very polarity: that it springs from the need of overcoming separateness, that it leads to oneness - and yet that individuality is not eliminated. Work is the other component; not work as a compulsive activity in order to escape aloneness, not work as a relationship to nature which is partly one of dominating her, partly one of worship of and enslavement by the very products of man's hands, but work as creation in which man becomes one with nature in the act of creation. What holds true of love and work holds true of all spontaneous action, whether it be the realization of sensuous pleasure or participation in the political life of the community. It affirms the individuality of the self and at the same time it unites the self with man and nature. The basic dichotomy that is inherent in freedom - the birth of individuality and the pain of aloneness - is dissolved on a higher plane by man's sponta¬neous action. The inability to act spontaneously, to express what one genuinely feels and thinks, and the resulting necessity to present a pseudo self to others and oneself, are the root of the feeling of inferiority and weakness. Whether or not we are aware of it, there is nothing of which we are more ashamed than of not being ourselves, and there is nothing that gives us greater pride and happiness than to think, to feel, and to say what is ours. This implies that what matters is the activity as such, the process and not the result. In our culture the emphasis is just the reverse. We produce not for a concrete satisfaction but for the abstract purpose of selling our commodity; we feel that we can acquire everything material or immaterial by buying it, and thus things become ours independently of any creative effort of our own in relation to them. In the same way we regard our personal qualities and the result of our efforts as commodities that can be sold for money, prestige, and power. The emphasis thus shifts from the present satisfaction of creative activity to the value of the finished product. Thereby man misses the only satisfaction that can give him real happiness - the experience of the activity of the present moment - and chases after a phantom that leaves him disappointed as soon as he believes he has caught it - the illusory happiness called success. There is another part just as compelling, one which is not rooted in bodily processes but in the very essence of the human mode and practice of life: the need to be related to the world outside oneself, the need to avoid aloneness. To feel completely alone and isolated leads to mental disintegration just as physical starvation leads to death. This relatedness to others is not identical with physical contact. An individual may be alone in a physical sense for many years and yet he may be related to ideas, values, or at least social patterns that give him a feeling of communion and “belonging.” On the other hand, he may live among people and yet be overcome with an utter feeling of isolation, the outcome of which, if it transcends a certain limit, is the state of insanity which schizophrenic disturbances represent. This lack of relatedness to values, symbols, patterns, we may call moral aloneness and state that moral aloneness is as intolerable as the physical aloneness, or rather that physical aloneness becomes unbearable only if it implies also moral aloneness. The spiritual relatedness to the world can assume many forms; the monk in his cell who believes in God and the political prisoner kept in isolation who feels one with his fellow fighters are not alone morally. …
0 Comments
Dusty old helmet, rusty old gun, they sit in the corner and wait. Two souvenirs of the Second World War that have witnessed the time and the hate. Mute witness to a time of much trouble where 'kill or be killed' was the law. Were these implements used with high honor? What was the glory they saw? Many times I've wanted to ask them... and now that we're here, all alone, relics all three of that long ago war... Where has freedom gone? Freedom flies in your heart like an eagle. Let it soar with the winds high above among the Spirits of soldiers now sleeping. Guard with care and with love. I salute my old friends in the corner. I agree with all they have said... and if the moment of truth comes tomorrow, I'll be free, or by God, I'll be dead! Audie Murphy, 1968 “On January 18, the government announced that it will change the legal status of the NCA and no longer permit any human settlement. This drastic move would forcibly remove approximately 100,000 people – primarily Maasai pastoralists – against their will. The government has set the goal of evacuating 20,000 people by March 2024.” (Mittal, 2024) For years now the government of Tanzania has been trying to remove local indigenous Africans from lands they deem as valuable for the tourism and hunting industries. This is absolutely devastating to the Maasai people, particularly the pastoral Maasai who are nomadic herdsmen by trade. For generations the Maasai people, whose everyday life and religion are deeply intertwined, have lived and communed with the land they are now being forcibly removed from. Many argue that not only do the nomadic tribes of the Maasai have a natural right to land they have been custodians of for many generations, but that the move entails relocating them to lands which can not support the incoming population. The government’s plan to move the Maasai away from the NCA is deeply flawed. As exposed by the Oakland Institute’s field research, relocation sites not only lack adequate water and grazing land, but the existing residents are being driven out to make way for those relocated – creating conflict. (Mittal, 2024) Many blame the World Bank Organization who has lent millions of dollars to the Tanzanian government so that they could complete investigations into claims made by the Maasai. Yet despite dumping more than $100 million into so-called ‘investigations’ of the rape, abuse, and forced evictions of the Maasai have only amplified. “It looks like instead of pressuring the government to stop its abuses, the launch of the investigation has led the government to intensify its plan for widespread evictions, letting TANAPA rangers continue their violence with impunity,” said Andy Currier, Policy Analyst at the Oakland Institute.” (Mittal, 2024) “The pastoral Maasai are fully nomadic, wandering in bands throughout the year and subsisting almost entirely on the meat, blood, and milk of their herds.” (Britannica) For the Maasai, their herds are their life, blood, and soul. The cattle they sustain their physical lives on are also what sustains them spiritually. By taking away their ability to herd their cattle on their ancestral land is denying the Maasai the right to practice their faith in their own way. Unfortunately, what took place on January 18, 2024 is just another in a long run of seizures and targeted attacks by the government on the Maasai people, as this type of harassment has been going on for quite some time. Back in 2023 ANAPA rangers seized farming equipment and fertilizer to stop people from cultivating their land during the critical beginning of the rainy season. That is when many communities decided to file their case with the regional East African Court of Justice. “Once captured, the cattle are auctioned off and exported from the area, unless the owners manage to get it back by paying a ransom to the authorities.” (Mittal, 2023) “Livestock is central to the Maasai culture and livelihoods. Losing cattle is therefore catastrophic for them. With this new tactic, the government’s goal is clearly to drive them away from their ancestral lands. (Mittal, 2023) From any outside perspective it seems clear that the government of Tanzania is trying to destabilize a community which has built its entire identity by going after its sense of security – its cattle and its grazing lands. It seems obvious, given the facts presented in the articles I read, the motives are greed. “The government is trying to suffocate the communities and make the situation uncomfortable for them,” says Denis Moses Oleshangai, a human rights lawyer at the Ramat and Jad Law Point law firm. “This is a war on the Maasai.” (Craig) “The agency called for more than 100 homes, churches, schools, medical dispensaries and administrative offices, including a police station, to be destroyed within 30 days of the order because they were built without permits, the agency claimed, even though some of the buildings were decades old, according to locals.” (Craig) Much of the protests by the Maasai has gone unheard, as the government claims they are only trying to do the right thing by the environment. “The government claims the Maasai and their herds are expanding and now represent a threat to conservation in Ngorongoro and the wider Serengeti ecosystem, home to a high concentration of endangered species including the black rhinoceros, elephant, wild dog and cheetah. “But the Maasai insist they have always lived in harmony with nature. Scientists and conservation experts agree. Last year, more than 275 researchers from around the world signed an open letter calling for a halt to eviction efforts.” (Craig) It is a catastrophic decision by the government to relocate so many people at one time. And by seizing their wealth, their cattle, as well as their lands, they have almost certainly doomed many of the tens of thousands of displaced Maasai to a generation of poverty, if not more. By taking their lands, the government is not only stripping the Maasai of their wealth, their homes, and their way of life, but also their community, their spiritual identity, and their religion (which is intrinsically tied up in their daily life as herdsmen). Through their actions the government is destroying an entire way of being – for profit. “The largest loss of land, however, has been to national parks and reserves, in which the Maasai people are restricted from accessing critical water sources, pasture, and salt lick. Subdivision of Maasailand reduced land size for cattle herding, reduced the number of cows per household, and reduced food production. As a result, the Maasai society, which once was a proud and self-sufficient society, is now facing many social-economic and political challenges.” (“Maasai Culture | Ceremonies and Rituals”) *by Raena Exe 01/28/2024 Resources: For More Read Here: https://www.oaklandinstitute.org/urgent-alert-tanzanian-government-rampage-against-indigenous-people Britannica, The Editors of Encyclopaedia. "Maasai". Encyclopedia Britannica, 17 Dec. 2023, https://www.britannica.com/topic/Maasai. Accessed 28 January 2024. Craig, Jess. ““It’s Becoming a War Zone”: Tanzania’s Maasai Speak out on “Forced” Removals.” The Guardian, 16 Jan. 2023, www.theguardian.com/global-development/2023/jan/16/tanzania-maasai-speak-out-on-forced-removals. “Maasai Culture | Ceremonies and Rituals.” Maasai-Association.org, maasai-association.org/ceremonies.html. Mittal. “URGENT ALERT: Tanzanian Government on a Rampage against Indigenous People.” Oaklandinstitute.org, 25 Jan. 2024, URGENT ALERT: Tanzanian Government on a Rampage Against Indigenous People. Accessed 28 Jan. 2024. Mittal. “URGENT ALERT: Tanzanian Government Resorts to Cattle Seizures to Further Restrict Livelihoods of Maasai Pastoralists .” Oaklandinstitute.org, 24 Jan. 2023, URGENT ALERT: Tanzanian Government Resorts to Cattle Seizures to Further Restrict Livelihoods of Maasai Pastoralists . Accessed 24 Jan. 2024. |
Archives
December 2024
Categories |